Monday, March 7, 2011

Alison Elizabeth Taylor

Marquetry-- pictures made with veneer, by Alison Elizabeth Taylor

Melissa Asis . Blog Entry #2

In chapter 2 of the “Critique Handbook” it begins the chapter about the meaning of meaning and significance. When the viewer views a piece of work there could be infinite meanings to what message is being said or what the artist wants to be seen. A piece of art can have more than one meaning to really no intentions of meaning anything. In order to get something out of a piece the artists uses many techniques to get the viewer to think about what is being shown. Related to all this it is very important to what medium is being used, what is included in the piece, the obvious and not so obvious, and so on.

The artist’s subject in a critique will have the audience think about whom or what is being shown along. When two pieces are being compared of the same figures there are a lot of times where the same subject can give the person critiquing it a different feeling of emotion. Another thing to look at is the artist, and also the person critiquing, his or her gender, race, sexuality, and religion. That can really make both people look at the piece very different, like the example of a male painting a nude female or a female painting a nude female and vice versa and the different feelings the person critiquing may feel about the certain artist painting that certain subject.

There is so much to think about when critiquing a piece. It really makes you think about what is being critiqued, by who, and the message being said. The meaning behind the piece is important and really ties in to who created the piece, the background of the artist, and the important. This chapter really asked a lot of important questions to the viewers and what to think about when critiquing and not just by simply looking at a piece but to get deep down into thought which also makes up for a good conversation for the piece.

Lauren Dubay: Reading Response: Chapter 2

Lauren Dubay: Reading Response: Chapter 2

This chapter of The Critique Handbook is appropriately called “The Story It Tells.” It discusses the different meanings of pieces of artwork and how those meanings are never absolute because they can change over time. It then goes on to define connotation and denotation of different aspects of a piece. In this section it explains how connotations are endless, by each viewer having their own opinions. The chapter then goes on to a section on loaded messages and brings up the point, for example, if it matters or not if the lighting in a photograph is bad even if it makes us a witness to a mass grave. Basically asking; do we or should we concentrate on the message of the formal elements if the piece is so compelling. Many different things can change ones view of a piece. Also, when a piece is very important to the artist the suggests that the commentary can become a personal attack. The reading asks if viewers should judge the formal elements if a piece is a terribly rendered depiction of the artists’ lost loved one. I feel that I have run into this problem several times, by wanting to comment on how the artist can improve but I am hesitant to speak up when I know the artist has worked so hard and their piece means a lot to them. I like how there is a part in this chapter that discusses the idea of a “loaded messenger.” It talks about how the identity of an artist affects a viewer’s opinion of a piece and I believe it does. When the artist is in the gallery with you while you look around, which typically happens here at San Jose State, your views change of their artwork? When people know the artist because they are well-known and for instants a particular piece is not the artist’s best work but a viewer may feel that they should like it anyways because they know they have liked other artworks by the same artist and/or simply because the artist is famous. The chapter goes on about nudes, specifically female nude. It gives different scenarios and explains the differences of piece’s meanings due to who composed them. Then the chapter discusses more and more about nude pieces. There is a small section on political artwork and how the meanings of those pieces can obviously change with time. Then has a part about aesthetic horror which I think can also be categorized as ironic art. There is next a section about how different things cause different meanings by imagery. Like how color can trigger certain memories or associations. I never thought of patterns as being associated with anything, but the few examples brought to light that there are many patterns that can be tied down to one meaning. The chapter makes a claim towards the end, that meaning can be explored by peeling back layers of imagery, which I think basically sums up this entire chapter.

Nichole's blog post 2

The Story it Tells lends to the idea that all works of art can be viewed in multiple ways. It is evident that the human perspective of artwork differs according to the work itself and the person actually viewing the work. The beauty of this world is the immense diversity that is present, and with the existence of different cultures, comes a difference in perspective- whether you are the art maker, or the art viewer.

When we think of the artwork itself we are considering the content, materials, subject matter, formal properties, placement, and we may consider the artists themselves. Interestingly when we think about critiquing a piece of work, a small hint, or a full background of the artist may make all the difference. Sometimes the use of color, for example, in an artwork, may be based on the cultural references affiliated with the piece. If we do not have that background, or even any hint to that information, our reading of the piece may be completely disconnected. In this case color has operated as content within the work, functioning in such a way that lends to a conceptual understanding, becoming symbolic in some works.

There is so much to consider when viewing a piece of work. Even factors such as gender and ethnicity may come into play, which also refers to the cultural aspect. Other elements we should consider are the time and place in which the artwork was made. This may easily dictate subject matter, as many artists find influence in the happenings of the world in which they live in. We may also have to consider a historical standpoint in that some artists reflect on the past, and find influence in that. Fortunately many artists tend to give certain elements in their work the foreground. When Kendal and Buster refer to the foreground they are considering the most obvious element present as you encounter the work. What element is the most obvious, that lends to a highlight of the artist style, and also a possible metaphor to the content of the work.

When viewing a work we must take all elements into consideration, even if these elements are not the one right before our eyes, ears, noses, etc. There is always the “why” that we must ask. We must ask because there is most often (if not all the time) a reason. A statement is always made in some way with artwork. Whether it is the most subliminal or the most obvious, there is a message. This message may be ambiguous, or straight to the point. The work may even encourage viewers to find multiple meanings. Knowing that everyone is different, we can assume that art is always being perceived in multiple ways.

This chapter helped to reinforce the fact that I must be very conscious when choosing materials and such for my projects. If I choose to use wood, why, and if I do use wood, is it the form or subject matter that transcends the meaning? There are so many elements that contribute to the meaning of art. Unfortunately we only have knowledge of particular things, and it is always a learning process to try new things. I believe it is fairly common for an artist to dream up a project that is out of their skill set. That is when areas of expertise seem to be where artists make their style known, and find what works for them.

Critique Handbook - Chapter 2

In chapter 2 of the Critique Handbook, Buster and Crawford look deeper into the granular nuances of art. The overarching focus in chapter 2 seems be to give more attention to the broader social aspects of the art and to give a critical clarity to the importance of the relationship between the art and the artist. They do this through a series of clear definitions and examples of formulaic methods that are very easy for the reader to grasp without the need to look at specific paintings either on-line or in person. They also expand the vocabulary of the artistic viewer and give a broader helping of methods for understanding the deeper societal aspects of art as a whole. The techniques outlined lend themselves to a greater understanding of where an individual artist might be communicating from with a particular work or body of work and should give both artists and critics a cause for reflection about what a work might be attempting to communicate beyond the artist’s approach to technical adherence.

Through clearly defining meaning, signification, denotation and connotation, content, subject matter and the subtle nuances of objectification, Buster and Crawford dissect the very nature of what could be construed as primitive or beginning works. Along with forcing the viewer to engage with the work and possibly understand the vast motivations and peculiar psyche of the artist, the viewer is also directed to connect with themselves and their own particular motivations and psyche. No work, regardless of its overarching simplicity, material choice, color, content or perceived/assumed hierarchy should be discounted until the viewer asks why its there and connects to it in such a way as to understand the motivations for its very existence in the first place.

What I came away with reading this chapter was a deeper respect for art outside my taste culture. I historically have disregard work when I didn’t find myself connecting to it esthetically on some level or if my initial response was that it academically inadequate in some capacity. In short, if I didn’t like it, I kept moving. What this chapter gave to me was a reason to stop and look again, and a vocabulary as to why that’s important. While almost impossible to discern the motivations of every individual artist that I encounter in my journey through appreciating the unfathomable amount of art around me, I can try to begin to understand why a particular piece doesn’t appeal to me and connect a little deeper as to the how and why of that encounter. In short, I can try to figure out why the artist was trying to speak to me, how they were attempting to do that and why they made the choices that they did to attempt to communicate with me the way they did. I often critique harshly but do so internally and try to embody respect for every endeavor as each moment that we dedicate is a reflection of our divinity. While idealistic and true, I am not always my best or particularly patient. In a way, chapter 2 of the Critique Handbook is about just that, being your best when you view a piece and being patient with both the work and the artist that is giving you the gift of their work.

Cody M. Reading response 2

All postings have been moved to February 21

Athena Chow, Chapter Dos

I found Chapter 2 of the Critique Handbook to be very interesting for its various definitions of ‘meaning’ and how they could be applied to critiquing art.

At the beginning of the chapter, Buster and Crawford stated how meaning is never infinite or stable. “Meaning can always change due to the work aging over time, misconceived intentions from the artist, earlier works from the artist, materials and processes of how the artist created his or her piece, art history references, and political and controversial events occurring.”

Meaning can also be influenced by who is giving voice to the piece and how it is delivered. The gender, ethnicity, culture, and age of the artist are all roles that come into play when a message is perceived by a viewer. For example, if the artwork was a painting depicting Asian females serving tea at a teahouse, this might be a referential to a viewer, in which the painting is depicting Chinese or Japanese culture. If it were Asian males depicted in the same scenario, this may bring up a controversy of whether there is intended sexual orientation or cultural references given by the artist. This could then offend those in the represented culture, and also cause notorious spotlight on the artist who created it in the first place. Having the artist’s gender identified for creating this kind of artwork could then allude to the artist’s personal background and inspiration.

Chapter 2 also gave insight when certain content can become too ‘loaded with a message’ and can cause uncomfortableness during a critique. If for instance a series of artwork revealed the bruises and wounds of a girl’s past abusive life, viewers may be hesitant in critiquing her work, for fear of being offensive or touching upon such a sensitive and personal issue. When works carry a more serious connotation to its meaning, such as large socio-political messages, critiquing the work of a piece can be much more difficult.

One particular part of the reading that I especially enjoyed was reading about the critique of a painting. A more experienced artist can tell if the surface of a painting was hesitant in its strokes or whether it was done smoothly in confidently. This can be taken into account for when critiquing the qualities of the form of an art piece.
I also learned that meaning can be broken down into two main parts. Meaning is first denoted, referring to what the form looks like, and then connoted, which refers to the artwork’s actual content.

I liked that the chapter went in depth over how color can be symbolic in meaning and can be self-referential in itself or provide further emotional meaning. I also appreciated learning how placement of an object can make a great deal on what the artist intended. For instance, is this object hiding in this corner or is it shamelessly protruding.

I overall enjoyed reading Chapter 2 and hope to apply many of its insights to my own upcoming project. Thinking about how a myriad of elements can affect the meaning of work, I’m going to especially pay particular attention to what materials I use and what constructed gestures I can capture within my used materials.