
http://thisiscolossal.com/2011/04/one-man-100000-toothpicks-and-35-years-scott-weavers-rolling-through-the-bay/
Class blog
Cutting Things Up, Tony Cragg
The tone of this reading is incredibly different from the previous two. Tony Cragg discusses some of the fundamental questions about art and material, meanwhile sending some strong critiques on the state of contemporary art.
“Material” and the act of making art are the primary focus at the beginning of the reading. Cragg describes the act of making art as a kind of journey- watching the changes unfold bit by bit and letting the process embed itself into the artist's psyche. In this process, according to Cragg, all the oversimplified classifications of art (form and content, abstract and figurative, etc) fall away into an unrestrained communication. It's here that we start to see the two main targets of Cragg's ire: modernism and utilitarianism. He calls modern art a “cold-hearted combination of elements taken out of a well functioning industrial reality” and considers utilitarian uses of material as an unpoetic waste of their potential.
According to Cragg, proper art is a representation of “humanity's understanding of itself at that time”. The old forms and images no longer properly convey the contemporary mindset, which is not to say that the old forms are obsolete, but that they've been transformed and re-contextualized. For instance, he notes, “The still life is no longer a demonstration of clever Dutch handwork or even, just the Duchampian acknowledgment of the industrial artefact as a carrier of metaphor and meaning. It has become any use of material that helps any figure exist in any given framework, essentially used as part of an existential strategy.”
To Cragg, utilitarian creation has created a “flood of meaninglessness” and destroys culture, reducing it to the level of the lowest common denominator. Art, on the other hand, “puts itself outside of some of the norms and standards which are binding for most people and becomes a testing ground for new forms and new meanings.” Art is the trend setter and the avant-garde, imagining the world so that the scientists and politicians can implement it.
I found this reading a bit unsatisfying. Not only is it disjointed and a bit shallow (which I imagine come from the fact that it is, I assume, the intro to the book- hopefully the ideas presented get fleshed out more later on), but the concept of the topic- what art is and what it can or should be- is quite tedious. I agree with most of what he says- especially the points about creating images, rather than appropriating and recombining existing images, and the drollness of utilitarianism (although there are exceptions)- but with so little elucidating of his points it really feels like he's just making his general philosophies known- if I didn't agree with him I certainly wouldn't be swayed by the chapter, and I don't feel any smarter after having read it.
Also, his casting artists as the vanguard of thinkers strikes me as, in a way, offensive and lazy. Cragg seems to portray progressive creative thought as being unique to artists, as if he is trying to force artists into specialists with a codified role in the industrial world. I've seen this idea welling in the minds of a few people now, and it always seems to operate on a crass stereotype, portraying scientists and engineers and such as automatons with no imagination. It also denies (or at least relieves) the artist the ability to carry out the ideas that they conceive of- turning them into a sort of unnecessary middle man. I see no reason why an artist should not be able to make their work something practical.
While reading “Cutting Things Up,” I felt like it was summarizing part of the reason I switch from science to art. Cragg says “Art puts itself outside of the norms and standards which are binding for most people and become a testing ground for new forms and new meanings.” (page 145) It was interesting to me that Cragg discusses science and politicians in comparison to art. I come from a background in science and politics. (I had some irrational desire to do environmental policy work, until I finally did an internship, which cured me of that idea.)
Science is an interesting beast. Depending on what secure of science you reside in, there is either little funding or tons. And with that funding comes restrictions. I personally was interested in the environment and ecology, which is on the little funding side of the spectrum. And of course when you throw politics into the equation, you find out that there is little desire to spend any big dollars to fund ecological research. One has to fund other more important spending projects. Artists on the other hand have freedom in what they choose to do.
Cragg discusses Da Vinci and Picasso. Ignoring Picasso, and sticking with the example of Da Vinci reminds us that artists were once sometimes referred to as “Renascence men,” in the sense that they studied everything. They studied science, medicine, art, etc. Men like Da Vinci were not boxed into one field. I personally feel that art and science go very well with each other. Art can be a form of experimentation, without the government restrictions based on who is footing the bill. “Artists rarely run away from the realities of the larger social and political issues. On the contrary, for those of us who feel outside of or, skeptical about the way in which politicians and others leads us into the future, art is a forum for real alternative thought and material solutions.” (page 145)
Cragg finishes by saying “One thing is for sure, the shape of the future is much too important to just leave to businessmen and politicians to decide upon it.” (page 147) It seems easy to forget that nothing exists separate of anything else. Nothing exists in a vacuum. That includes art. Art responds to the environment in which it was created. I make art that deals with environmental issues because I not only have a degree in ecology, but because I live in a political and social environment that is grappling with the consequences the industrial revolution and a consumer throwaway society that is always hunting for the newest gadget. Unlike Da Vinci, we have become divorced from the natural world, and grow up in suburbs driving SUVs.
Now, I am not going to argue that art will have the answers. I know that I don’t have the answers. However, what I felt Cragg was encouraging was unrestricted experimentation. And we as artists have the luxury to do exactly that.
Cutting up materials does more than what’s happening to the material. It also transforms ourselves, our feelings, out thoughts into something that didn’t exist before. By shaping a new form, a new meaning takes shape. This is also true with other media, such as drawing, painting and writing because they all use materials that allow us to open up a new door and see something new, like poetry, once engaged in a deep level.
On the contrary, we are surrounded by things that are made without much thoughts, feelings or complicated processes: a cube, a Mickey Mouse, a photograph, a size, a material, a colour, a meaning. The author, Tony Cragg describes that they are made “not by creating something new but by the cold-hearted combination of elements taken out of a well functioning industrial reality”. They create mysticism and not power or potential to explore and discover something new or a new meaning.
Traditionally artists create forms and images, which are reflected upon the artist’s knowledge, history and beliefs, as well as perception about humanity and world at that time. Such evidence has been found in many works of masters, such as DaVinci and Picasso’s figure, landscape or still life pieces.
Today we live in a world where almost every material on this planet has been altered by mankind and hardly any nature exists. Despite the artist’s intension, meaningless stuff, including our surroundings, urban, rural and natural, are mass-produced at a high speed due to mainly economic growth. Cragg refers this phenomenon as “uncomplicated economic utilitarian normality”. He even goes further and criticizes politicians that it’s the result of “economic exploitation unintelligence and simple laziness.” And it’s destroying cultures and nature with “simple parameters and dumb geometrics”.
Regardless, artists continue to address social and political issues by using art as a platform for alternative solutions. Artists help others dream the dreams and pursue them eventually, like landing on the moon. This is because artists have a way to make others to recognize and have a meaningful life. With that special skill, artists ought to be responsible for presenting their perceptions of reality and understanding the material, which makes us and our lives.
I believe that artists are dreamers, dream which we never stop dreaming. However, are we able to continue dreaming while more and more meaningless materials are being produced in the world? For example, (ugly) mini-malls, unattractive unified block structures (which nobody likes) throughout the United States. What about children in future? Where will their imaginations or dreams come from? It’s our duty as an artist to recognize such problems and present alternative solutions through artistic practices to create a vision and values for people (so that they are not in a hand of government or alike).
In chapter 2 of the “Critique Handbook” it begins the chapter about the meaning of meaning and significance. When the viewer views a piece of work there could be infinite meanings to what message is being said or what the artist wants to be seen. A piece of art can have more than one meaning to really no intentions of meaning anything. In order to get something out of a piece the artists uses many techniques to get the viewer to think about what is being shown. Related to all this it is very important to what medium is being used, what is included in the piece, the obvious and not so obvious, and so on.
The artist’s subject in a critique will have the audience think about whom or what is being shown along. When two pieces are being compared of the same figures there are a lot of times where the same subject can give the person critiquing it a different feeling of emotion. Another thing to look at is the artist, and also the person critiquing, his or her gender, race, sexuality, and religion. That can really make both people look at the piece very different, like the example of a male painting a nude female or a female painting a nude female and vice versa and the different feelings the person critiquing may feel about the certain artist painting that certain subject.
There is so much to think about when critiquing a piece. It really makes you think about what is being critiqued, by who, and the message being said. The meaning behind the piece is important and really ties in to who created the piece, the background of the artist, and the important. This chapter really asked a lot of important questions to the viewers and what to think about when critiquing and not just by simply looking at a piece but to get deep down into thought which also makes up for a good conversation for the piece.
The Story it Tells lends to the idea that all works of art can be viewed in multiple ways. It is evident that the human perspective of artwork differs according to the work itself and the person actually viewing the work. The beauty of this world is the immense diversity that is present, and with the existence of different cultures, comes a difference in perspective- whether you are the art maker, or the art viewer.
When we think of the artwork itself we are considering the content, materials, subject matter, formal properties, placement, and we may consider the artists themselves. Interestingly when we think about critiquing a piece of work, a small hint, or a full background of the artist may make all the difference. Sometimes the use of color, for example, in an artwork, may be based on the cultural references affiliated with the piece. If we do not have that background, or even any hint to that information, our reading of the piece may be completely disconnected. In this case color has operated as content within the work, functioning in such a way that lends to a conceptual understanding, becoming symbolic in some works.
There is so much to consider when viewing a piece of work. Even factors such as gender and ethnicity may come into play, which also refers to the cultural aspect. Other elements we should consider are the time and place in which the artwork was made. This may easily dictate subject matter, as many artists find influence in the happenings of the world in which they live in. We may also have to consider a historical standpoint in that some artists reflect on the past, and find influence in that. Fortunately many artists tend to give certain elements in their work the foreground. When Kendal and Buster refer to the foreground they are considering the most obvious element present as you encounter the work. What element is the most obvious, that lends to a highlight of the artist style, and also a possible metaphor to the content of the work.
When viewing a work we must take all elements into consideration, even if these elements are not the one right before our eyes, ears, noses, etc. There is always the “why” that we must ask. We must ask because there is most often (if not all the time) a reason. A statement is always made in some way with artwork. Whether it is the most subliminal or the most obvious, there is a message. This message may be ambiguous, or straight to the point. The work may even encourage viewers to find multiple meanings. Knowing that everyone is different, we can assume that art is always being perceived in multiple ways.
This chapter helped to reinforce the fact that I must be very conscious when choosing materials and such for my projects. If I choose to use wood, why, and if I do use wood, is it the form or subject matter that transcends the meaning? There are so many elements that contribute to the meaning of art. Unfortunately we only have knowledge of particular things, and it is always a learning process to try new things. I believe it is fairly common for an artist to dream up a project that is out of their skill set. That is when areas of expertise seem to be where artists make their style known, and find what works for them.
This chapter of the handbook deals with the meaning of art as well as how an artwork does not have a single meaning. As a work ages, the meaning of the work will change as well as political controversy that the work is surrounded by. The materials used for the artwork also contribute to the meaning. Paint, wood, color, chalk, and pencil each affects the painting in its own way. The three crucifixes is an example of how color and positioning of the crucifix can alter the meaning. The upward motion and lighter color has an emphasis of Jesus while the earthy, closer to the ground does not. Knowing the artists is an important factor in determining its meaning. The idea of nude paintings is an example of how if a male painted it or whether a female painted it. Meaning could change when information about the artists emerges, for example, their previous works would have an impact on the newer works. If an artist is known for creating works dealing with life, one could assume that the meaning of all his works is dealing with life. The signification of an artwork is not simple as well. The art may have a meaning behind it but a person might interpret it differently. A simple installation of a car would have no real significance, but if it were old, damage, or any other form of impact on the car, the significance of the car would change. In a literary sense, certain phrases can have multiple meaning. In addition, an artwork can denote something but connote something different. A light bulb may denote a light bulb, but connotes an idea or technology. A subject matter that overwhelms the normal formal elements will grab a viewer’s attentions. Some may be so overwhelming that having a serious critique is impossible. When an artwork has some emotional and personal meaning behind it, could a person comment on it without any hesitation? I think that a painting that has a major emotional attachment to it is difficult to critique, if the person knows the story. If the story is unknown, commenting on the artwork should be no problem. However, some artworks are very straightforward on the meaning behind it, which makes it difficult to critique without having an emotional conflict with it. Political art is very controversial when critiquing. This reading has got me thinking on how to give my artworks a meaning that I intended it to have. The materials used, the subject matter and the type of person I am will have an impact on how others will see my work. Knowing this, having a focus now and staying with it will evidently impact how others view my work.
I think I talked a little bit about chapter 2 in my first blog, so I’ll try not to be too repetitious. It gets really confusing reading the same book for two classes, so I apparently got a little ahead of myself.
Chapter 2 talks about meaning in work, and how different works can potentially read different depending on how it is composed or what materials are chosen, etc. Imagery and materials are often loaded with meaning, be it art historical, political or cultural. Therefore it is very important that we as artists are aware of the meaning of imagery and materials.
In the project that I am currently working on, I am making very conscious decisions of materials and imagery knowing that depending on what I use, it will carry different meaning. I am dealing with research, specifically research dealing with endangered species within California. I am hanging my species from string; being very conscious of what metaphor this can refer to. I am not just arbitrarily hanging them. Endangered species are on the verge of extinction; therefore the metaphor I am employing is that they are “hanging by a thread.”
In another project I am working on, I am attempting to make a critique or commentary on our use of water bottles. I am choosing plexiglass, which is a kind of plastic, specifically because of the fact that water bottles are made out of plastic.
Going back to my endangered species project, I had to think very hard about where I placed my map of the California counties. The book discusses the problem of pedestals. Pedestals for me became problematic on multiple accounts. For starters, my map is potentially going to be too big for a pedestal. Tables are problematic because they are distracting and also constraining based on size constraints. Should I place it on the floor? What does that mean for it to be on the floor? My original idea would be for the species to be hanging above their specific counties like ghosts. But would the viewer really make this connection is the counties are so far below the species? So I asked myself the question, why couldn’t the counties be above the species and the species hanging down from them? They would still be ghost like. And because they are hanging from the counties, they are falling away from their native habitats.
I got a little carried away this time, sorry if it's too long!
Whereas the first chapter of The Critique Handbook focuses on the formal elements of a work of art, and elucidates the factors that need to be taken into consideration, this chapter examines how those formal choices create meaning in the work. Above all else it must be stressed that meaning, in fine art, is slippery, potentially multiple, often open to interpretation, and highly dependent on the context surrounding the work. Even in language, a system designed explicitly for communication, there are ambiguities (the double entendre relies on this), and the context can easily change the connotation of a message.
Representative art begins with a layer of meaning in the form of denotation- the recognizable objects that the work is depicting. On their own, the represented objects may carry a meaning, but more often it is only when the image of the object is activated (by means of context, material, construction, affect, etc) that it begins to become significant. An object in of itself rarely has a significance, especially when considered at too high of a level of abstraction: a sculpture of “a boy” could be meaningless, but if it is a sculpture of “a boy in a dress crying” then new layers of significance arise- the rendering of his dress and his crying are denoted, but the message itself is connoted. In a representative work, the connotations that the work will evoke are all wrapped up in the subtleties of the execution of the image. The reading gives examples of two still lives of flowers, one blooming with life and the other withered and dead.
Even without considering representation, however, there are myriad opportunities to create meaning through the formal choices surrounding a work. The general rule of thumb seems to be dependent on the idea that there is a sort of “status quo” regarding any formal choice in the art world; canvases for painting are usually rectangles, sculptures are usually made out of bronze or marble and usually rest on pedestals, skies are usually blue, etc. Only when a work breaks these norms that a given formal choice becomes foregrounded. A purely aesthetic painting of a still life will never be read as such if it's painted with the artist's blood, and using oil paints to refer to an oil spill will most likely fly under most critics radars.
Every formal consideration that was discussed in the last chapter is discussed here as well, in the context of creating meaning. Creating meaning is an exercise in creating connections to the real world- what kinds of things are small in a big room, and what does scale infer? What kinds of things are blue, and how do those blue things reflect on the object at hand? Site-specificity takes on a whole new life when examining the message of the work, because it no longer relates only to the physical dimensions of the place but of the entire history, culture, and context of the area, not only in space but in time as well. A sculpture of a Vietnamese man would be read drastically different in Vietnam today than in the US during the Vietnam War.
Highly important in the reading is the question of the artist's identity, which comes into play most significantly when the artist is dealing with sociological meanings. There aren't simple ways to codify these interactions, but they most often come up when someone starts making art that represents the condition of someone other than themselves. The reading gives the example of four paintings of nude women, made by four individuals of different genders, ages, and temperaments. Because the identities of the artists and the handling of the subject matter changes so drastically, the paintings are read significantly differently.
Overall I felt the reading was helpful. It laid out the basics of reading art in the sort of “you knew it but needed it spelled out” kind of way. What I found most interesting was the “Color as Index” section, and the idea of creating a highly parseable language within the work itself. Ultimately I don't find the act of decryption very interesting, and some of the methods of creating meaning presented in the reading feel like that- they create a 1:1 correlation between a form and an idea in order to express a message, but in doing so they create (and even celebrate) a huge amount of room for ambiguity. There is a difference between poetic truths and factual truths, and there's certainly room for ambiguity and interpretations in some cases, but if you have a clear thesis show it some respect and communicate it clearly.
When we look at a piece of art, we first examine formal choices made by the artist, such as materials, surface treatment/gesture (brush strokes, etc), composition, color, texture, scale, position and how it’s made (process). Then we try to understand why the artist made such choices, as well as the artist’s intension. To get to that point, it’s important to know what “meaning” is and how it’s embedded in a work of art.
Sometimes the subject matter weights more than the content unintentionally by the artist when the subject matter is so strong, such as gender, race, sexuality, ethnicity, handicap, etc. That could lead to an incorrect interpretation of art by the viewer. “Who tells the story” also has a major impact on the content. The identify of the artist, such as gender, ethnicity, culture can influence the meaning of art. Objectifying other person (people) as the subject can make things complicated even further and it may not reveal the artist’s meaning as it was intended. The new way of viewing the art in such perspective has derived from the fact that the rise of feminism in the late 1960s and early 1970s and discoveries of “non-Western” artists. Who behind the work became very critical as to analyzing the work of art. It shouldn’t be the focal point, yet without it, art may not be complete.
When looking at a work of art, we immediately notice an element that stands out the most. In other words, it’s been foregrounded. Then we begin investigation of the art further by careful examination of each formal element, such as form, color (refers to certain emotion, symbol, index), pattern, palette, a theatre (placement), configurations, composition, gesture (act of art making), material, process, etc which will land to a meaning.
To understand the meaning of art is complex. We must consider not only what’s visible but also what’s behind the work as well as who is the maker. I do agree that it’s important to know who the artist is, what’s his/her background is, what/who influenced the artist, and any other factors or life related to the artist as detail as possible in order to fully understand the intention/meaning of the particular art, therefore, provide a good and constructive criticism.
When looking at art, a myriad of actions process in our minds. We see its color, its shape; the immediate natural responses take place. The reading refers to a pieces’ form and content line, wherein lies the art. Where is the work placed, on the form end of the line, or the content end? That’s were the critique begins, or ends. I better understood this through the red rectangle example. Untitled #3 vs. After the Massacre. We see the large painted rectangle as two different things when a simple thing as a title is given. But other factors can alter ones view on the painting, for example if the painting was painted with actual blood, compared to the same painting done with acrylic paint. Perhaps the “untitled #3” was painted with pig blood, and “slaughterhouse” was painted with oil. The content-and-form line where the “art” gets placed is suddenly in a pickle.
The reading mentions Anthony Caro and him commenting on the period of time where it was difficult to create a sculpture that did not remind him of something else. Caro must have seen a lot of work. He proposed a problem, and through what the reading explains, the work to be evaluated had to be done so formally, understanding and seeing the piece as a whole, by means of its shape, color, parts, material and weight. A pillow for example is soft, reminds one of sleep. But take the very same pillow, but create it in carved stone, suddenly the pieces’ content changes. Do I think of the difficulties some face when sleeping? Or is this an artist’s rendition of a caveman’s sleeping accessory?
A discrete object in space, where a sculpture is a work consisting of a singular object, or a work expressed by multiple parts, are both read as a single form. How this form gets shown in a gallery is something of another feat. Taking a work and placing it on a pedestal is one way. Incorporating a pedestal to that same piece, whether it be made of the same material, or follow lines already occurring in the artwork and be constructed independently in another material will definitely cause the viewer to have more thought in what he or she has to say about the work. Instead of the art having a footprint consisting of the pedestal it rests on, the art could be larger (or smaller) depending how the pedestal is incorporated into the work. The pedestal could then be considered part of the art, rather than being the slave the work uses to be shown off to.
This reading proposes new ideas and ways of thought that are new to me. Applying the concepts into my own ways and reasoning when I go out and view and critique others artists’ work will definitely be an new experience.
While reading the first two chapters of The Critique Handbook, I was reminded of one of the first things I learned as an undergrad in the very first art class I took: you have to think about everything you do in art, and have a reason for it. As I have matured as an artist, I have run into many critiques where I will be asked why I used one material versus another. This especially has become problematic for my paintings. The first chapter discusses painting, and how for many painters they have simply accepted the rectangular canvas as a “neutral ground on which to hang a painting.” (page 13) The next section starts to ask various questions about the logic of painting. How big the work, is it painted on a canvas or on something else. As an aside, while reading this I remembered a conversation I had about one of my paintings I did my first year of grad school. I had painted a pile of burning bottles on a large canvas in oil. The scene was from Afghanistan, and was taken by my friend in the army. It was showing where the army dumps the hundreds of thousands of plastic water bottles that the American soldiers stationed there go through. A question I received about it was why did I paint it on a canvas? Wouldn’t it have more meaning if it were painted on say, an army backpack? The form and the meaning of a piece of work are often tied together, and the book discusses.
The first chapter covers form in terms of painting and sculpture. It raises various thoughts about looking at a painting, and how the artist approaches the painting, representational versus abstract, etc. When discussing the sculptural object, there is a section that discusses the problems of presentation. Canvases are hung on the wall, and framing or not framing, leaving the sides exposed or not exposed all come into question for a painting. However, with sculpture, the problem of how to present them within the room, and how to deal with elevating them or not elevating them on a pedestal comes into play. Does the pedestal create a discussing with the art, or disappear into the background? Should the piece stand on its own? Should it hang from the ceiling? All of these issues create dialogue with the piece and can change the meaning.
In the second chapter of the book, it discusses meaning. Meaning is never exactly fixed and can be open to interpretation. Meaning is molded by the choices that the artist places in the art from content, form, materials, etc. It also discusses how similar content can have different meaning if presented in different forms.
As an artist it is hard to anticipate how all your choices about what to include will affect your audience. People will often get different meaning from the same object. The section discussing the pedestal got me thinking about my current project that I am working on. I have yet to resolve the issue of what I will place one of the major components of the project. The part of the project that needs to be propped on something is a map of California that will most likely be made out of vacuform plastic. The problem is no matter what I place it on; it needs to be functional and yet not distracting. It was a lot simpler when I stuck with works on paper or canvas, since as the book point out; they are often just taken on face value and not overly questioned.