Monday, February 28, 2011

Y Tanaka - The Story It Tells

When we look at a piece of art, we first examine formal choices made by the artist, such as materials, surface treatment/gesture (brush strokes, etc), composition, color, texture, scale, position and how it’s made (process). Then we try to understand why the artist made such choices, as well as the artist’s intension. To get to that point, it’s important to know what “meaning” is and how it’s embedded in a work of art.

“Meanings” are not absolute as we live in a society, which is changing politically, socioeconomically, environmentally, technologically, historically, personally, etc., in flux, therefore meanings change, too. “Signification” is interpreting its meaning and it’s embedded in a complicated world. It depends on who is speaking, where they are, who is being addressed, how the message is delivered, and what the circumstances are, etc. When we look at a piece of art, we first notice what we can see obviously (“denote”), then how we can read it or make sense out of it (“connote”). “Content” and “subject matter” are different. For example, subject matter is denotative and content connotative. Furthermore, how the work was done (process) is a determining factor for content or meaning, and not what was created (subject matter). The work can also be read/interpreted according to how the work is presented by the artist - “descriptively” or “prescriptively”.

Sometimes the subject matter weights more than the content unintentionally by the artist when the subject matter is so strong, such as gender, race, sexuality, ethnicity, handicap, etc. That could lead to an incorrect interpretation of art by the viewer. “Who tells the story” also has a major impact on the content. The identify of the artist, such as gender, ethnicity, culture can influence the meaning of art. Objectifying other person (people) as the subject can make things complicated even further and it may not reveal the artist’s meaning as it was intended. The new way of viewing the art in such perspective has derived from the fact that the rise of feminism in the late 1960s and early 1970s and discoveries of “non-Western” artists. Who behind the work became very critical as to analyzing the work of art. It shouldn’t be the focal point, yet without it, art may not be complete.

When looking at a work of art, we immediately notice an element that stands out the most. In other words, it’s been foregrounded. Then we begin investigation of the art further by careful examination of each formal element, such as form, color (refers to certain emotion, symbol, index), pattern, palette, a theatre (placement), configurations, composition, gesture (act of art making), material, process, etc which will land to a meaning.

To understand the meaning of art is complex. We must consider not only what’s visible but also what’s behind the work as well as who is the maker. I do agree that it’s important to know who the artist is, what’s his/her background is, what/who influenced the artist, and any other factors or life related to the artist as detail as possible in order to fully understand the intention/meaning of the particular art, therefore, provide a good and constructive criticism.

Monday, February 21, 2011

Jan Michael Cruz: Blog One

When looking at art, a myriad of actions process in our minds. We see its color, its shape; the immediate natural responses take place. The reading refers to a pieces’ form and content line, wherein lies the art. Where is the work placed, on the form end of the line, or the content end? That’s were the critique begins, or ends. I better understood this through the red rectangle example. Untitled #3 vs. After the Massacre. We see the large painted rectangle as two different things when a simple thing as a title is given. But other factors can alter ones view on the painting, for example if the painting was painted with actual blood, compared to the same painting done with acrylic paint. Perhaps the “untitled #3” was painted with pig blood, and “slaughterhouse” was painted with oil. The content-and-form line where the “art” gets placed is suddenly in a pickle.

The reading mentions Anthony Caro and him commenting on the period of time where it was difficult to create a sculpture that did not remind him of something else. Caro must have seen a lot of work. He proposed a problem, and through what the reading explains, the work to be evaluated had to be done so formally, understanding and seeing the piece as a whole, by means of its shape, color, parts, material and weight. A pillow for example is soft, reminds one of sleep. But take the very same pillow, but create it in carved stone, suddenly the pieces’ content changes. Do I think of the difficulties some face when sleeping? Or is this an artist’s rendition of a caveman’s sleeping accessory?

A discrete object in space, where a sculpture is a work consisting of a singular object, or a work expressed by multiple parts, are both read as a single form. How this form gets shown in a gallery is something of another feat. Taking a work and placing it on a pedestal is one way. Incorporating a pedestal to that same piece, whether it be made of the same material, or follow lines already occurring in the artwork and be constructed independently in another material will definitely cause the viewer to have more thought in what he or she has to say about the work. Instead of the art having a footprint consisting of the pedestal it rests on, the art could be larger (or smaller) depending how the pedestal is incorporated into the work. The pedestal could then be considered part of the art, rather than being the slave the work uses to be shown off to.

This reading proposes new ideas and ways of thought that are new to me. Applying the concepts into my own ways and reasoning when I go out and view and critique others artists’ work will definitely be an new experience.

sara gevurtz' blog 1

While reading the first two chapters of The Critique Handbook, I was reminded of one of the first things I learned as an undergrad in the very first art class I took: you have to think about everything you do in art, and have a reason for it. As I have matured as an artist, I have run into many critiques where I will be asked why I used one material versus another. This especially has become problematic for my paintings. The first chapter discusses painting, and how for many painters they have simply accepted the rectangular canvas as a “neutral ground on which to hang a painting.” (page 13) The next section starts to ask various questions about the logic of painting. How big the work, is it painted on a canvas or on something else. As an aside, while reading this I remembered a conversation I had about one of my paintings I did my first year of grad school. I had painted a pile of burning bottles on a large canvas in oil. The scene was from Afghanistan, and was taken by my friend in the army. It was showing where the army dumps the hundreds of thousands of plastic water bottles that the American soldiers stationed there go through. A question I received about it was why did I paint it on a canvas? Wouldn’t it have more meaning if it were painted on say, an army backpack? The form and the meaning of a piece of work are often tied together, and the book discusses.

The first chapter covers form in terms of painting and sculpture. It raises various thoughts about looking at a painting, and how the artist approaches the painting, representational versus abstract, etc. When discussing the sculptural object, there is a section that discusses the problems of presentation. Canvases are hung on the wall, and framing or not framing, leaving the sides exposed or not exposed all come into question for a painting. However, with sculpture, the problem of how to present them within the room, and how to deal with elevating them or not elevating them on a pedestal comes into play. Does the pedestal create a discussing with the art, or disappear into the background? Should the piece stand on its own? Should it hang from the ceiling? All of these issues create dialogue with the piece and can change the meaning.

In the second chapter of the book, it discusses meaning. Meaning is never exactly fixed and can be open to interpretation. Meaning is molded by the choices that the artist places in the art from content, form, materials, etc. It also discusses how similar content can have different meaning if presented in different forms.

As an artist it is hard to anticipate how all your choices about what to include will affect your audience. People will often get different meaning from the same object. The section discussing the pedestal got me thinking about my current project that I am working on. I have yet to resolve the issue of what I will place one of the major components of the project. The part of the project that needs to be propped on something is a map of California that will most likely be made out of vacuform plastic. The problem is no matter what I place it on; it needs to be functional and yet not distracting. It was a lot simpler when I stuck with works on paper or canvas, since as the book point out; they are often just taken on face value and not overly questioned.

Athena Chow, Response #numero Uno

As students, artists, and viewers alike, I think we tend to subconsciously critique art pieces in the order of form first, and then content. Our perception of artwork is first form, because form, as described by Kendall and Paula, is the elements we naturally observe when first encounter an art or design piece: shape, size, color, scale, composition, etc. Our visual impression, is then followed usually by a curiosity for wanting to understand the piece better. When we search for content, we are usually looking for some sort of narrative, information, or deeper meaning behind the piece that could be alluding from the piece’s title or even from the form itself—this is called formalism, as noted by The Critique Handbook.

As I further read the handbook, I learned that many aspects should be taken into account for when giving a critique. Is the artwork based off of accurate realism? Or of abstraction that includes some reality to it and yet also some distorted imagination? Is the artwork an object representing a mimesis-- an imitation-- of another object or experience? Is this a nonrepresentational piece with no real underlying structure from our reality? What kind of lines are drawn—soft, hard, contour-like, scribbly, straight, accidental, or intended? Do the colors give me a certain elated emotion when looked upon? Or are they clashing and giving me a sense of anxiousness? Does the framing, format, and edges of the piece help add to the content or visual aesthetic intended by the artist? Do I see a correlative message that pertains to the idea of something political, historical, personal, fictional, or perhaps, even nothing at all? Do I associate this piece with something I’ve seen or experienced before? On what scale is the piece being displayed? Is the piece carrying some miniscule, tentative details that needs to be scrupulously observed over? Or is the piece made part of a room, an installation, that is causing me as a viewer, to take part in a magnified sensory experience? What materials and process did the artist use to arrive to his or her final masterpiece? Wood, cardboard, plastic, paint, found material, tape, glue? Were special adjustments needed to assemble the work, such as prop-ups and pedestals, to give the illusion of suspension and gravity?

After reading the first chapter of The Critique Handbook by Kendall Buster and Paula Crawford, I felt like I was more formally informed on the technicalities of critiquing. When I first read Kendall and Paula's introduction of how critiques tend to be given with the formal ‘praiseworthy’ and ‘complaining’ sort of comments-- a made example of this could be, "This ceramic elephant has superb detailed-craftsmanship in its meticulously painted colors and patterns, but I think its sculpted ears and hind legs could have been made a bit more proportional."--I kind of smiled to myself about this. First, because this typical way of critiquing rang so true, and secondly, because I had never really given thought to the formal dissection of a critique-- I found it interesting to learn about the formal terminology and many little aspects that encompassed proper critiquing. As a 3rd-year art and design student who has participated in many classes and critiques herself, I found The Critique Handbook to be quite helpful and interesting, especially in the areas of certain critiquing details that I had not known before. I definitely feel like some of the terms within the handbook could help me express my next critique more intellectually and succinctly.

Kendall and Paula overall, did an excellent job on elaborating and giving an in-depth overview of the various aspects that could be analyzed within a critique.

Cody M. reading responses

Reading Response 4

 Titling a piece is a very powerful move, but it is often a necessary to convey the true message of a piece. The example of the red square is used over and over again in the reading. The same subject matter has different meaning because of the subject that is supposed to represent. The first example is of the Israelites crossing the red sea, or having crossed the sea, with the Egyptians being swallowed up behind them…this is represented by a red cube, representative of the mood of the piece, of anger, triumph, and even pain. The red cube is also described as being representative of a psychological mood, and another is a landscape from Moscow, titled red square.  The entire point of this passage to tell us that these nearly identical pieces, have very different subject matter, and corresponding titles. In the reading, it is later talked about an artist creating a piece of work which is untitled and has no description.  The reading examines this…what weight does this piece have with no story and no title? My issue is that art can be worthwhile without these things. Artwork can be aesthetically correct, or beautiful. If this red square was examined, and it showed that it was of some perfect proportion, of that is was a particularly beautiful hue of red, it would be just as important as another red square that has a title and a meaning. Who knows, maybe the fact that a particular red square having no title and meaning adds to its mysteriousness and forces people to try and go deeper into thought beyond what the artist had thought of.
In the next section, where the raising of Jesus’ hand is examined for deeper meaning. Is
His hand raised, has it just been raised, the fact that it is raised means that it is not lowered, is it a bodily movment or is it being purposefully raised by its owner. I feel that anyone who reads this passage will be much better equipped to answer the question, which came first, the chicken or the egg; or maybe they people who read this in the first place are already adept enough to answer that question.
The next section for me was confusing. This passage about a mirror was difficult for me to understand, but I do agree with the writers final statement, that the artist J has convinced me that this mirror, a mere a object (haha, a mere mirror) is somehow a piece of art.

 Reading Response 3

I found the writing on page 5 talking about how artist are the dreamers and dreamers particularly powerful. “Artists and poets landed on the moon long before any astronaut did, travelled through space and time, teletransported, practiced non-invasive medicine, and almost everything else one can think of before they were invented.”  This is a very true statement! The job of the artist is to be imaginative, to think of what has not been done, and how to do it differently. To be an artist, one must also be a mathematician, a story teller, a chemist, a designer, a philosopher, a craftsman, and anything else in-between. The limitation of the artist then becomes what the artist is experienced with in terms of materials and media.
As a sculptor, I have a certain amount of control over the piece I am making, but eventually there is a point where the piece I am working on no longer resembles the initial idea I had. This is because of limitations in the particular media I am working with, or new ideas I have had to make the piece better. An interesting point the writing makes is that art today is more of a political message, or that the art is based on conveying a message versus showing innovation based on art form. I agree with this to an extent…just like in the past, when there were innovations in figure drawings, still life’s and landscapes, there are still innovations today that still have artistic relevance. Using new tools and methods such as CNC based sculpting techniques, new materials such as carbon fiber to make ultra lightweight sculpture, or using computers and printers to produce exact pieces of art still have merit. They do not need to have a message to be art. That being said, we are reaching a point where so many different uses for media have been explored that to have new different art, one must have a powerful different message.  Duchamp turned the art world upside down with his ‘fountain’, making all art conceptual…when will see another Duchamp who will change the art world again and give us new ideas and possibilities to explore?

 Reading Response 2

Once again, the critique handbook! Oddly enough to me, I found some parts of this chapter particularly insightful. Chapter 2 is all really about meaning…how variations may change a piece of arts significance and/or meaning. This can be very important, because it takes artwork beyond just being aesthetically pleasing to something that has cultural significance. A particularly insightful part of the text I found was the section dealing with religion, titled “the Loaded Message.” In this section of the reading, It is discussed about how many pieces of art, which may not be correct (not having correctly proportioned figures, or using awkward color combinations) will be praised or even cherished because of the religious figure or message depicted. In my own opinion, so of my favorites of these are depictions of the Christ child with his mother from the Dark ages. Baby Jesus in these paintings looks more like a giant monster that will grow to be a 9ft tall behemoth. Early artist were able to get away with this because of the religious message of the painting, and In my opinion, no one wanted to talk down a religious painting, even if it was incorrect. I understand that some artwork has meaning but I feel that this ability to attach meaning to artwork has caused abuse of meaning. I have a joke of whenever a person asks what message I was trying to convey with my artwork, I reply with that this piece is a reflection of our counties lack of motivation to provide aid to countries that we have been ravaging for decades. I usually say this as a joke, but I have seen this in a lot of galleries on and off campus, and it is my opinion that people are becoming too attached to the meaning of their artwork. Just like it is written in the critique hand book, many people can use the color red as their primary card swath, and will be able to have their artwork as being angry because of the color choice. My question is simply, what happened to the artwork made simply to have good artwork? Not all art has to has a ridiculous meaning attached to it (either by the artist or the audience) Art as a whole needs to go back to its roots to when art was just about form…although, that would be kinda impossible. Art has been a way of story telling and teaching the different meanings of life for thousands of years. Maybe meaning isn’t such a useless pain…although if someone asks me why I chose to use plastic for a particular project and asks if it is a critique on our dependence on foreign oil, I might just scream!

Reading Response 1

The reading was mostly about how to, not so much critique artwork, but how to analyze artwork from all angles. We were asked as critique-ers to think about not only the finished product but to also consider the process that the material went through from raw to finish. We were also asked to use this knowledge of material and the construction/deconstruction process to see how the message of the artwork changes.

We also found that the meaning of artwork can change immensely simply with a change
in the title. Although obvious, I found the passage on page 4 especially helpful . This passage, which discusses a hypothetical monochrome red painting initially is untitled, making it a color study and not much else. However, this piece is greatly changed when it is titled something like “after the massacre” changing this piece to a reflection of a probable real world event. My own interpretation of this would be a painting with unknown title of rugged sailors/pirates from the 1700’s stealing cargo. If one were to rename it “Tea Party” the viewer would immediately know this is a reference to the Boston tea party of colonial America. In addition, the more historically savvy viewers would then try to find certain famous revolutionaries in the painting making it all the more successful.

The rest of the reading was pretty straight forward. Like I said, we were asked to consider all the different aspects of the art pic, from typs of material for construction, through tools used in that construction process, to the finishing polish or color on the piece. A large portion of this reading simply summarized these different processes.

I didn’t quite agree with the reading completely however. I felt that the writers(s) really focused on the narrative of the finished art piece. The authors want us to analyze how the material, title, context, ect, effect the meaning of the art piece. My question is: “why cant art just be compositionaly good, and just that?” How do you attach a narrative to an untitled paint splatter by Jackson Pollock? Wouldn’t some deeper meaning potentially degrade the quality of the artwork? My point that I am trying to make is that sometimes a great piece of art doesn’t not need a narrative and that an attached narrative will cause the human mind to attach both obvious and subconscious meaning to a piece, thus changing the value of the piece between each viewer.

My only other criticism of the reading is the fact that on numerous occasions, the authors made conclusions so complex and full of art jargon that the sentence almost became unreadable. This was so bad that at almost every one of these encounters, the writers then restated their position, often starting with the term “in other words” and stating a simple and easy enough sentence to understand. From a pure writing standpoint, this made the reading exceptionally tedious.

Wilson - Reading Assignments

Cragg - Cutting Things Up


Critique Handbook - Chapter 1

The handbook shows us how to critique an artwork and show what questions to ask when critiquing.

Many people think that form is the container that holds the content for an artwork. In its simplest term, form is the mean by which a person gives substance to their idea.

Form differs in sculptures and paintings. In a sculpture, the form of that sculpture is its weight, density, mass, proportion, and the three dimensional shape. In a painting, form is there in the painting's composition, texture, pallet, and line quality. In a sculpture, all it's form is made up of an infinite number of shapes.

In looking at a sculpture, we begin by looking the relation it has with the space it occupies. We have to ask where the sculpture ends and the space that it occupies end. This is important because the negative space in a sculpture is important. Even if the artist have not considered the space around their sculpture, the space around it is still important to look at.

The way a piece of sculpture is presented affects its form.

When a sculpture is suspended, it allows it to defy gravity. In a critique, we have to look at why it is suspended and what it suspending the sculpture. So the question of is suspension really necessary is raised. Is suspension the best choice for the sculpture or might it be better off freestanding? The materials used to suspend it is important also. If a heavy chain is used to suspend the sculpture, it becomes part of the sculpture.

When using a pedestal, the question is raised of where the artwork actually begins. The pedestal can be seen as a way to raise the sculpture to a person's eye level. The pedestal also affects how a person percieves the artwork. The height and where the pedestal affects the perception of a sculpture.

The way a sculpture is propped up can affect how a person views an artwork. The materials used to prop up the sculpture becomes part of the artwork. Do the prop ups look like it was done to be part of the sculpture or does it look like something done in the last minute?

From this reading, I'm starting to question if all the props of guns and swords I made are sculpture pieces. They are made for costumes and I usually take photographs of the props without the costumes. So do those props have the same meaning when they are away from their costumes, away from it's context? Or do they have enough meaning on their own to be a free standing piece of art?

Y Tanaka - Form Matters

When critiquing art works, we look at forms first whether it’s a painting, sculpture or other media. Forms can be the physical form of a sculpture, as well as formal elements, such as scale, shape, size, composition, and color. Formalism emphasizes these formal elements in art and art making process. It can hinder a narrative content but also be self-referential. The modernism changed the value of formalism. Visual elements were celebrated and embraced rather than a reference to create an image, which was the focal point for pre-Modernists. Abstraction is not self-referential because it doesn’t remind one of something else. On the other hand, realism is self-referential, which can be easily associated with characters or something familiar, therefore, it helps developing a story, just like how a novel works. However, the definition of realism is depending on how artists view “reality”.

When critiquing a painting, we should consider edges, line, color, composition, fields, scale, format, surface, gesture, and process. The painting is also an object, rather than surface. It can be a platform for a performance act. It is also a mechanism to deliver a narrative content. Critiquing sculptures are conducted in a similar fashion. The criteria includes, the object as well as discrete object spatial/compositional relationships, footprints, gravity, suspended pieces, pedestals, and prop-ups, ratio, the room spatial relationship, fields, the expanding, exploding, or meandering form, formal considerations within the object, mass and shape, material and process, construction, material/process as form, as action, and illusion and integrity of material. When an installation can take up an entire exhibition space, the installation piece becomes architecture. Material and process are a very integral part of the form, as well as developing a concept. For example, I constructed miniature trees, one made out of a thread, the other computer wires. I deliberately selected these materials, which I coiled one by one around tiny-trees. Both materials and the process support my concept, which depicts a technological transformation, nature versus man-made materials.

Kendall Buster and Paula Crawford often associate their content with music or writing practices, which I thought was fabulous. They said, “Greenberg argued for a kind of painting that refuses to be the carrier of a narrative, much the way a symphony is a complex structure whose emotional and expressive content relies purely on the structural relations set up by the composer. Color, line, repeated motifs are orchestrated across the surface of the canvas much the way melody, harmonic textures, and repeated motifs are arranged by the composer.” An individual visual element doesn’t mean much, just like a simple notation. But if it’s combined with one or more elements (e.g., one or more notations), it gives a meaning/life, just like creating a complex the structure/system or having an orchestra. Interesting comparison…… and yes, form matters.