This chapter of the handbook deals with the meaning of art as well as how an artwork does not have a single meaning. As a work ages, the meaning of the work will change as well as political controversy that the work is surrounded by. The materials used for the artwork also contribute to the meaning. Paint, wood, color, chalk, and pencil each affects the painting in its own way. The three crucifixes is an example of how color and positioning of the crucifix can alter the meaning. The upward motion and lighter color has an emphasis of Jesus while the earthy, closer to the ground does not. Knowing the artists is an important factor in determining its meaning. The idea of nude paintings is an example of how if a male painted it or whether a female painted it. Meaning could change when information about the artists emerges, for example, their previous works would have an impact on the newer works. If an artist is known for creating works dealing with life, one could assume that the meaning of all his works is dealing with life. The signification of an artwork is not simple as well. The art may have a meaning behind it but a person might interpret it differently. A simple installation of a car would have no real significance, but if it were old, damage, or any other form of impact on the car, the significance of the car would change. In a literary sense, certain phrases can have multiple meaning. In addition, an artwork can denote something but connote something different. A light bulb may denote a light bulb, but connotes an idea or technology. A subject matter that overwhelms the normal formal elements will grab a viewer’s attentions. Some may be so overwhelming that having a serious critique is impossible. When an artwork has some emotional and personal meaning behind it, could a person comment on it without any hesitation? I think that a painting that has a major emotional attachment to it is difficult to critique, if the person knows the story. If the story is unknown, commenting on the artwork should be no problem. However, some artworks are very straightforward on the meaning behind it, which makes it difficult to critique without having an emotional conflict with it. Political art is very controversial when critiquing. This reading has got me thinking on how to give my artworks a meaning that I intended it to have. The materials used, the subject matter and the type of person I am will have an impact on how others will see my work. Knowing this, having a focus now and staying with it will evidently impact how others view my work.
Monday, March 7, 2011
Kevin Tam Reading #2 blog
Sunday, March 6, 2011
Friday, March 4, 2011
sara gevurtz' blog 2
I think I talked a little bit about chapter 2 in my first blog, so I’ll try not to be too repetitious. It gets really confusing reading the same book for two classes, so I apparently got a little ahead of myself.
Chapter 2 talks about meaning in work, and how different works can potentially read different depending on how it is composed or what materials are chosen, etc. Imagery and materials are often loaded with meaning, be it art historical, political or cultural. Therefore it is very important that we as artists are aware of the meaning of imagery and materials.
In the project that I am currently working on, I am making very conscious decisions of materials and imagery knowing that depending on what I use, it will carry different meaning. I am dealing with research, specifically research dealing with endangered species within California. I am hanging my species from string; being very conscious of what metaphor this can refer to. I am not just arbitrarily hanging them. Endangered species are on the verge of extinction; therefore the metaphor I am employing is that they are “hanging by a thread.”
In another project I am working on, I am attempting to make a critique or commentary on our use of water bottles. I am choosing plexiglass, which is a kind of plastic, specifically because of the fact that water bottles are made out of plastic.
Going back to my endangered species project, I had to think very hard about where I placed my map of the California counties. The book discusses the problem of pedestals. Pedestals for me became problematic on multiple accounts. For starters, my map is potentially going to be too big for a pedestal. Tables are problematic because they are distracting and also constraining based on size constraints. Should I place it on the floor? What does that mean for it to be on the floor? My original idea would be for the species to be hanging above their specific counties like ghosts. But would the viewer really make this connection is the counties are so far below the species? So I asked myself the question, why couldn’t the counties be above the species and the species hanging down from them? They would still be ghost like. And because they are hanging from the counties, they are falling away from their native habitats.
Thursday, March 3, 2011
Book Surgeon
http://www.mymodernmet.com/profiles/blogs/the-book-surgeon-15-pieces
Wednesday, March 2, 2011
Mold of a Parking Meter
Marek Kapolka: Reading 2: Chapter 2 of The Critique Handbook
I got a little carried away this time, sorry if it's too long!
Whereas the first chapter of The Critique Handbook focuses on the formal elements of a work of art, and elucidates the factors that need to be taken into consideration, this chapter examines how those formal choices create meaning in the work. Above all else it must be stressed that meaning, in fine art, is slippery, potentially multiple, often open to interpretation, and highly dependent on the context surrounding the work. Even in language, a system designed explicitly for communication, there are ambiguities (the double entendre relies on this), and the context can easily change the connotation of a message.
Representative art begins with a layer of meaning in the form of denotation- the recognizable objects that the work is depicting. On their own, the represented objects may carry a meaning, but more often it is only when the image of the object is activated (by means of context, material, construction, affect, etc) that it begins to become significant. An object in of itself rarely has a significance, especially when considered at too high of a level of abstraction: a sculpture of “a boy” could be meaningless, but if it is a sculpture of “a boy in a dress crying” then new layers of significance arise- the rendering of his dress and his crying are denoted, but the message itself is connoted. In a representative work, the connotations that the work will evoke are all wrapped up in the subtleties of the execution of the image. The reading gives examples of two still lives of flowers, one blooming with life and the other withered and dead.
Even without considering representation, however, there are myriad opportunities to create meaning through the formal choices surrounding a work. The general rule of thumb seems to be dependent on the idea that there is a sort of “status quo” regarding any formal choice in the art world; canvases for painting are usually rectangles, sculptures are usually made out of bronze or marble and usually rest on pedestals, skies are usually blue, etc. Only when a work breaks these norms that a given formal choice becomes foregrounded. A purely aesthetic painting of a still life will never be read as such if it's painted with the artist's blood, and using oil paints to refer to an oil spill will most likely fly under most critics radars.
Every formal consideration that was discussed in the last chapter is discussed here as well, in the context of creating meaning. Creating meaning is an exercise in creating connections to the real world- what kinds of things are small in a big room, and what does scale infer? What kinds of things are blue, and how do those blue things reflect on the object at hand? Site-specificity takes on a whole new life when examining the message of the work, because it no longer relates only to the physical dimensions of the place but of the entire history, culture, and context of the area, not only in space but in time as well. A sculpture of a Vietnamese man would be read drastically different in Vietnam today than in the US during the Vietnam War.
Highly important in the reading is the question of the artist's identity, which comes into play most significantly when the artist is dealing with sociological meanings. There aren't simple ways to codify these interactions, but they most often come up when someone starts making art that represents the condition of someone other than themselves. The reading gives the example of four paintings of nude women, made by four individuals of different genders, ages, and temperaments. Because the identities of the artists and the handling of the subject matter changes so drastically, the paintings are read significantly differently.
Overall I felt the reading was helpful. It laid out the basics of reading art in the sort of “you knew it but needed it spelled out” kind of way. What I found most interesting was the “Color as Index” section, and the idea of creating a highly parseable language within the work itself. Ultimately I don't find the act of decryption very interesting, and some of the methods of creating meaning presented in the reading feel like that- they create a 1:1 correlation between a form and an idea in order to express a message, but in doing so they create (and even celebrate) a huge amount of room for ambiguity. There is a difference between poetic truths and factual truths, and there's certainly room for ambiguity and interpretations in some cases, but if you have a clear thesis show it some respect and communicate it clearly.
