Monday, February 21, 2011

Wilson - Reading Assignments

Cragg - Cutting Things Up


Critique Handbook - Chapter 1

The handbook shows us how to critique an artwork and show what questions to ask when critiquing.

Many people think that form is the container that holds the content for an artwork. In its simplest term, form is the mean by which a person gives substance to their idea.

Form differs in sculptures and paintings. In a sculpture, the form of that sculpture is its weight, density, mass, proportion, and the three dimensional shape. In a painting, form is there in the painting's composition, texture, pallet, and line quality. In a sculpture, all it's form is made up of an infinite number of shapes.

In looking at a sculpture, we begin by looking the relation it has with the space it occupies. We have to ask where the sculpture ends and the space that it occupies end. This is important because the negative space in a sculpture is important. Even if the artist have not considered the space around their sculpture, the space around it is still important to look at.

The way a piece of sculpture is presented affects its form.

When a sculpture is suspended, it allows it to defy gravity. In a critique, we have to look at why it is suspended and what it suspending the sculpture. So the question of is suspension really necessary is raised. Is suspension the best choice for the sculpture or might it be better off freestanding? The materials used to suspend it is important also. If a heavy chain is used to suspend the sculpture, it becomes part of the sculpture.

When using a pedestal, the question is raised of where the artwork actually begins. The pedestal can be seen as a way to raise the sculpture to a person's eye level. The pedestal also affects how a person percieves the artwork. The height and where the pedestal affects the perception of a sculpture.

The way a sculpture is propped up can affect how a person views an artwork. The materials used to prop up the sculpture becomes part of the artwork. Do the prop ups look like it was done to be part of the sculpture or does it look like something done in the last minute?

From this reading, I'm starting to question if all the props of guns and swords I made are sculpture pieces. They are made for costumes and I usually take photographs of the props without the costumes. So do those props have the same meaning when they are away from their costumes, away from it's context? Or do they have enough meaning on their own to be a free standing piece of art?

Y Tanaka - Form Matters

When critiquing art works, we look at forms first whether it’s a painting, sculpture or other media. Forms can be the physical form of a sculpture, as well as formal elements, such as scale, shape, size, composition, and color. Formalism emphasizes these formal elements in art and art making process. It can hinder a narrative content but also be self-referential. The modernism changed the value of formalism. Visual elements were celebrated and embraced rather than a reference to create an image, which was the focal point for pre-Modernists. Abstraction is not self-referential because it doesn’t remind one of something else. On the other hand, realism is self-referential, which can be easily associated with characters or something familiar, therefore, it helps developing a story, just like how a novel works. However, the definition of realism is depending on how artists view “reality”.

When critiquing a painting, we should consider edges, line, color, composition, fields, scale, format, surface, gesture, and process. The painting is also an object, rather than surface. It can be a platform for a performance act. It is also a mechanism to deliver a narrative content. Critiquing sculptures are conducted in a similar fashion. The criteria includes, the object as well as discrete object spatial/compositional relationships, footprints, gravity, suspended pieces, pedestals, and prop-ups, ratio, the room spatial relationship, fields, the expanding, exploding, or meandering form, formal considerations within the object, mass and shape, material and process, construction, material/process as form, as action, and illusion and integrity of material. When an installation can take up an entire exhibition space, the installation piece becomes architecture. Material and process are a very integral part of the form, as well as developing a concept. For example, I constructed miniature trees, one made out of a thread, the other computer wires. I deliberately selected these materials, which I coiled one by one around tiny-trees. Both materials and the process support my concept, which depicts a technological transformation, nature versus man-made materials.

Kendall Buster and Paula Crawford often associate their content with music or writing practices, which I thought was fabulous. They said, “Greenberg argued for a kind of painting that refuses to be the carrier of a narrative, much the way a symphony is a complex structure whose emotional and expressive content relies purely on the structural relations set up by the composer. Color, line, repeated motifs are orchestrated across the surface of the canvas much the way melody, harmonic textures, and repeated motifs are arranged by the composer.” An individual visual element doesn’t mean much, just like a simple notation. But if it’s combined with one or more elements (e.g., one or more notations), it gives a meaning/life, just like creating a complex the structure/system or having an orchestra. Interesting comparison…… and yes, form matters.

Dan S. Reading response


Critique Handbook Chapter 1

This chapter of the book discusses the many potential elements of a work of art. Each characteristic is broken down and an example of how it might apply to a piece of art is given. There are also sections that discuss the relationship between certain elements and how these characteristics can help a piece of art convey its meaning to the viewer. The main focus is how to critique these attributes and is discussed along with possible questions that the viewers can ask themselves when examining art. Both spatial and pictorial works are discussed and some famous critics opinions are also included throughout the chapter. The main point this article brought to mind is the critique of an artwork as a whole. There can be many layers and meanings to a work and reading the chapter reminded me of the many distinctive components that a work can contain. This chapter covers quite a bit and all of it can be useful when examining a work of art.

While reading this chapter I started to think of how the application of form could be used with the material I am working with and how to manipulate the material in two ways: how to convey form without the material impacting that image and how to effectively use the material without changing its appearance. If I don’t come up with something satisfactory for either of these goals then I will probably focus on how to change the appearance of the materials.
The overall focus of this chapter to me was the relationship between the characteristics covered and how to go about discussing each part of a work in relation to the other parts. The sections that compared the potentially opposing traits in a work were interesting as they pointed out these may not be so different. There are other points that the article brought up in my mind. Abstraction and shape versus reality and how these two traits are influence on the final product. How to effectively convey meaning without sacrificing the intent or the goals behind the creation of a work. When creating a work that is not site-specific how often does the artist take into account the potential spaces that work might be placed in or displayed? How to effectively use a space to increase the understanding or meaning of work? How to make a spatial work that is strong enough to convey it’s meaning regardless of the space it is placed in? I don’t see this problem with pictorial works as they can be perceived as separate from the area they are placed in and can be placed in a frame that may or may not be used to enhance the message of the work.

kevin tam reaadddinggzzzz

The content of this handbook focuses on how to properly critique almost any type of art work. It discusses what a person needs to know when going into a critique and the ability to understand the artwork. When looking at a painting formally or a sculpture formally, you have think about what makes the painting a painting or what makes the sculpture a sculpture. It talks about if a real painting done on a canvas or could it be expanded on different mediums. It asks if a painting is the same whether it is done academically or done on the streets. How would one critique if the painting is a representation; does each stroke on a painting needs to be analyzed. The chapter also talks about when materials are chosen for an artwork, does it matter what materials are used; does paint have a better quality than a projection or a photograph. Also how would one critique an art when the painting is abstract compared to realistic; would one critique it the same or differently. The reading goes on talking about sculpture and whether if the pedestals, base of a sculpture, should be seen as an art. According to what a sculpture should be, then the pedestals should be considered part of the art since its part of the entire space. If the pedestal would be part of the art, the ratio of the pedestal to the surroundings must be considered. The use of a type of material can dramatically improve the artwork. When modeling, casting, and carving, you are adding or removing. The reading brings up many points that I feel could help me with my projects. Incorporating objects that would not normally be seen in art to form a sculpture. How could you use a plaster for its plasterness in an art? How would clay by itself be used to make something unique.

Melissa Asis . Reading Assignment 1 / Ch. 1

In this reading it talked about many things that people use to critique a work of art. There are many ways that an artist and/or student will say about another’s work and how to make it look better or how well it already looks well done. It goes into detail about how the mind works when thinking about a piece whether it is on paint and canvas, sculpture, or digital design. People critique a piece with what exactly is on their mind when thinking about how the artist went by making it. When a person looks at a piece and it has a name to it already then it helps the person critiquing it figure out what he/she is looking at but if there isn’t a name that goes with the piece then the person critiquing it will come out with something abstract. Abstraction itself is a broad term because it defines itself as being “nonrepresentational”. With a piece being nonrepresentational it gets a little more difficult to even critique something because there are a million questions and especially one being of “what exactly am I looking at?” This is where a person really needs to use logic and really question oneself of the design, colors, medium, and shape, and so on to come to a conclusion. Once we come to a conclusion and understanding of what was produce then we can look at what is represented in the piece and what form it brings on. The reading goes on about formalists and what is represented in the pieces and what qualities it brings. As it goes on about form and what it represents then it has us thinking about realism and how much the artist captured the piece from a realist point of view. It questions on how much detail was brought into the piece and is it enough to get what is trying to perceive.

I think this reading is to give us an idea of how to come across our classmates pieces and to look into detail how well the piece is made and how it was made. Instead of just looking at a piece and saying, “it looks good”, we need to give an explanation towards why it is a well made design and to ask as many questions as we can towards the students work. It also has me thinking of how to apply certain ideas from different points of views for whatever object or figure I work on and how to present it.

Not quite sure if what I want to do for my projects but I am working on trying to get something to work on.

L. Dubay Reading 1

This first chapter of The Critique Handbook discusses an array of ways to critique art. It focuses on the formal matters of how to critique and analyze art. It begins with form and content and then speculates about how analysis of a piece can triggers questions. The example given of a red painted rectangle with a simple title of “Red Rectangle” gives an entirely different message than the same piece titled “After the Massacre.” Which now makes me think about how an artist’s title of a piece influences me? The chapter then proceeds to discuss formal praise and complaints. The examples given seem to be standard critique where one says what they like about a piece then gives an example or suggestion on how it may be improved. The next sections are about formalism and modernism, and abstracting and abstraction. These two topics bring up questions that are answered in several points. If an abstraction of an image maintains its recognizable traits of an object or if it is just a reference to something real, which is abstraction or realism? This brings up the many questions on how to critique realism versus abstraction. If a piece is not as close to looking real as it possibly can be with the materials given, should it still be classified as realism or abstraction? It states that, what is real all depends on what the source is. Many artists learned their craft through looking at mirror or photographs. These visuals are flat references that are aiding flat images, so how real can realism get? Then the chapter talks about how associations need to be recognized in a critique. People need to see a likeness in a piece.

The chapter then goes on in detail of different elements of types of artworks. There is a part that discusses what the ingredients are for a painting to be categorized as a painting and if a painting is still a painting without some of the essential tools. It talks about edges and how they define the outer edge of a painting and where the pictorial space ends and the rest of the world begins. This reminds me of many paintings that have clean crisp edges that are obviously taped off on purpose. I have also seen several where the artist has a defined edge but intentionally meander past it and continues an element in the picture in that stark space. It then talks about how when people discuss composition of a piece they always speak of the formal analysis of the composition, which they were taught of in school. The chapter then goes on about elements of formal sculpture critique. There are many good specific examples of ideas expressed in this section. In this sculpture section there is information on what elements to think of on how to display sculptural pieces. The materials and process section discusses how, in sculpture, the material sometimes dictates the process or the process dictates what materials to use. Then it tells about how materials used to be used in one a few ways with a few processes, but now lots of different materials are being used in a variety of ways. The process of construction starts with a list of materials that can be used with a list of processes that can work with those materials.

blog01

What is art? Art is something which is hard to quantify. The readings doesn't answer what is art but focuses on the point of how to look at it and how it can be categorized into reconizable pieces. "Formal Matters" is just the beginning on how to think about critiquing art. The chapter begins with a discussion of form vs content in order to talk about composition. Is the composition tell a story or does its placement relate to formalist qualities?Does one have a greater value over the other? Will narrative be more important than the objects themselves? Without narrative do objects become formulaic, following formalist rules?

Does being able to paint, draw or sculpt with machine like accuracy make one a better artist? Does photo realistic renditions say more or less then a cartoon character? Technique an craftsmanship are appreciated in the arts but are they necessary? Where should the line be drawn?

“The challenge to be a realist, is no longer a necessity, though

considered a praiseworthy skill.”

- Nichole

I have to agree with Nicole on this point, with the invention of modern technology it becomes less and less important to imitate reality. With a camera it is possible to capture reality quicker then is possible with drawing. Harold Edgerton a photographer known for his stop action photos considered himself a scientist rather than an artist though many of his photographs are considered art. The benefits of art that I see is not in capturing reality but in creating the imaginary.

The section on realism got me thinking. What we say is real is based entirely on our perception so if we reverse it, what we cant not perceive is therefore not real. Taking this one step further, imagine a sculpture stored inside an ordinary box and the sculpture is something that will never be observed by an audience. Playing with the idea of reality in the mind of the viewer. To the viewer the sculpture does not exist since it can not be perceived.

Did the chicken come first or the egg? Do I make the work using these artistic elements or do I make the work relying on intuition to guide then later attributing artistic elements to it? Many of my ideas begin with a humorous narrative which I then abstract and simplify. It is my worry that by following a rigid set of theories my work will end up being formulaic and predictable.

Just wanted to say I never did this blogging thing before so not sure if I'm doing this right. ^_^